top of page
Estrutura celular translúcida em_edited.

CH 11 | LIFE:

What does life have to do with consciousness?

Estrutura Vesicular Translúci (1)_edited

WHICH LIVING BEING SEPARATED FEELING FROM OPERATION?

​A single-celled being, such as an amoeba, detects changes in its environment in a functional sense, registers their effects, and modifies its responses through homeostatic exchanges.

​

We call this biological operation: functional sensitivity to the environment, something broadly accepted among biologists and philosophers. We need not attribute a non-useful subjective experience to the amoeba.

​

Billions of years later, we find countless organisms in which we recognize subjective experience in their very way of operating.

If we have found no evidence of an evolutionary rupture that suddenly switched on subjectivity in living beings across their different lineages,

​

what entitles us to treat subjective experience and function as separate realities?

​

What entitles us to say that the subjectivity of experience is a mere addition, dispensable to operation?

​

If, when looking at an amoeba, we recognized sensitivity as an integral part of operation, at what point in evolution did we decide to separate them? Must we then say that the amoeba has subjective experience and devise an additional explanation to connect feeling to operation, when the very separation between them has not even been demonstrated?

Does increasing complexity entitle us to say that feeling became subjective and ceased to be functional?

​

Since when has becoming more complex meant becoming felt, while ceasing to be functional?

​

Does our anthropocentrism, and our use of an individual lifespan as a temporal reference, entitle us to ignore what the long timescale of our own lineage reveals?

​

If billions of years unfolded within a single life, would you understand better? We gained the capacity to feel the photograph of experience without the full capacity to observe the film thatconstituted it.​

EVOLUTION DOES NOT HAVE TO PROVE UNION. THOSE WHO PROPOSE SEPARATION MUST JUSTIFY IT.

​​​​​​​​IS A HUMAN BEING MORE INTELLIGENT THAN A BACTERIUM?

​

Our dictionaries tell us that intelligence is the ability to learn from experience, solve problems, and adapt behavior to new situations, producing effective solutions. Therefore, a human being is more intelligent than a simple bacterium. To us humans, this claim seems so intuitive as to be almost obvious.

​

Perhaps because we ourselves chose the measuring stick.

Bacteria have inhabited this planet for billions of years. We, Homo sapiens, for roughly 300,000.

​

We, the self-proclaimed intellectually superior, acknowledge that we might bring about our own extinction—through wars, environmental collapse, or resource scarcity.

​

If we declared war on all bacteria, we would put our own survival at risk. They inhabit our bodies, take part in our digestion, and sustain processes essential to life on the planet.

Even without such a war, a pathogenic bacterial lineage could still pose a grave threat to humanity.

​

Bacteria can continue without us. We cannot continue without them. Evolutionary success and intelligence are not equivalent when we think in photographs. But when we look at the film of Cognitive Darwinism, the perspective changes.

​

SO WHAT DOES IT MEAN TO BE MORE INTELLIGENT?

​

By our own criterion of intelligence, the being that stages the greatest operational spectacle while spending more energy solving problems it created itself does not strike me as more intelligent.

We did not win the test of intelligence; we were merely the only species that, ingeniously, invented a concept of superiority that does not apply to itself.

​

We need to rethink how we classify this planet's living beings on our own scale of intelligence and, when searching for intelligent life beyond it, ask whether we seek a mirror or a difference.

​

WHAT DIES WHEN MATTER REMAINS?

​

You remain alive while your matter is continually replaced. But when an organism dies, almost all of that matter remains—and some cells stay alive for a while longer. Life persists through the replacement of its parts without requiring a metaphysical substance; death can arrive before those parts disappear. If the ingredients are still present, what exactly has ceased to continue?

​

WHO PERFORMS THE WORK OF LIFE?

​

There is another paradox. By removing components from a system to discover the minimum requirements for life, scientists may end up performing the work the system itself has ceased to do. The smaller the candidate for life, the greater the invisible work of the laboratory sustaining it may become. Providing resources is not the same as performing its operations for it. Intelligence does not demonstrate life; artificial origin alone does not rule it out either.

​

The test changes its target: identifying functions associated with life is not enough. We must discover whether the system itself performs the work that sustains its continuity—or whether we are crediting it with what another system does on its behalf.​​

​ASTROBIOLOGY: WHAT IF WE WERE THE EXOTIC LIFE?

​What if the consciousness of another form of life were not merely a different way of seeing our world, but a way of existing from which the world is encountered, carved out, and perhaps felt differently?

 

We try to explain what consciousness is using the very measuring stick that simultaneously attempts to define it. What we fail to find under the microscope, we will not find through the telescope. As anthropocentric beings, are we searching for intelligent life or for life resembling what our measuring sticks can recognize?

​

When we look up at the sky, are we truly searching for other forms of life and mind—or only for a mirror that returns our own voice?

​

What if even our anthropocentric interpretation of consciousness were a function shaped by evolution? What if feeling like the center of the world is operationally useful even when it is not true?

WHAT DIES WHEN MATTER REMAINS? HOW CAN A LINEAGE GIVE RISE TO OTHER CONSCIOUSNESSES?

TECHNICAL OVERVIEW

SCIENTIFIC FOUNDATIONS & THE LIFE TABLE

Across 76 pages, Chapter 11 integrates theoretical and evolutionary biology, origins of life, artificial life, organizational autonomy, and astrobiology to investigate what constitutes the continuity of a living organization. The investigation includes comparative tests, a complementary computational proposal, and 12 hypothetical reconstructions of life.

​

SCIENTIFIC & PHILOSOPHICAL FOUNDATIONS

​

01 · DEFINING LIFE — Cleland and Chyba question the limits of terrestrial definitions derived from a single known biosphere.

​

02 · ORGANIZATION & AUTONOMY — Maturana and Varela (autopoiesis), Mossio and Montévil (closure of constraints), and Ruiz-Mirazo and Moreno (basic autonomy) investigate the organization of life.

​

03 · MATERIAL & EVOLUTIONARY CONTINUITY — Research on cellular renewal, material turnover, inheritance, and evolutionary lineages examines continuity through transformation.

​

04 · BIOLOGICAL BOUNDARIES & ARTIFICIAL LIFE — Research on viruses, biological individuality, artificial life, and biohybrid systems confronts the replication of functions with the constitutive work of life.

​

THE LIFE TABLE — COMPARATIVE INVESTIGATION

The TMC articulates these research traditions through the Inside–Between–Ahead Triad, proposing a common causal-temporal yardstick, rather than an inventory of properties.

The Life Table examines 32 entries across 3 comparative matrices, confronting the Triad with 4 traditional criteria — metabolism, reproduction, thermodynamics, and terrestrial biochemistry — under 8 analytical controls: instance, scale, time window, causal closure, resource versus operator, recurrence, triadic coherence, and control of retrospective adjustments.

The comparison covers living systems, boundary cases, abiotic phenomena, artificial organizations, and hypothetical extraterrestrial candidates, distinguishing evidence, interpretation, conditional prediction, and uncertainty.

​

EXPERIMENTAL EXTENSION — TONONI & THE TMC

In Chapter 11b, a computational research proposal engages with Giulio Tononi's Integrated Information Theory (IIT), comparing three regimes: fixed structure, adaptation with external maintenance, and adaptation with modeled internal maintenance.

The hypothesis investigates whether initially similar organizations develop different trajectories when causal integration, plasticity, and maintenance costs interact.

One thing is to identify what an organization loses when we divide it. Another is to investigate the work it must perform to continue existing and transforming itself.

The proposal has not yet been executed or validated and does not constitute a direct test of subjective experience.

​

05 · ASTROBIOLOGY & POSSIBILITIES OF LIFE

Neveu and Green investigate criteria for detecting extraterrestrial life. Research by Hurford, McKay & Smith, Vanag & Epstein, Prindle, Daly, and Boothby, among others, provides physical, chemical, and biological precedents for exploring possibilities of life beyond terrestrial patterns.

​

EXPERIMENT X — TWELVE POSSIBLE FORMS OF LIFE

Drawing on these precedents, the TMC constructs 12 hypothetical organizations. Through the ARCO-TMC method, it examines constitution, continuity, access to the world, self-reference, time, and trajectory, ultimately asking:

What would it be like to exist — and, hypothetically, to feel — from within such an organization?

The exploration reverses the perspective: rather than searching for our own image in other forms of life, it questions our very way of recognizing life.

Scientific mechanisms provide partial constraints, not proof that these organisms or their subjective experiences exist.

​

THE TMC'S PROPOSED CONTRIBUTION

The TMC investigates life through codependent directions of a single causal trajectory, applying the same yardstick across different materials, organizations, and timescales.

Life is not determined merely by what a system contains or performs, but by the causal organization that sustains and reconstructs its own continuity.

The Life Table tests the hypothesis's consistency; the Tononi extension proposes a computational investigation; Experiment X explores its philosophical boundaries.

Conceptual consistency does not replace independent empirical validation.

DOWNLOAD FULL CHAPTER · PDF

Âncora 1

Intelligence is not enough for life;
artificiality is not enough to rule it out

CH 11a | OVERVIEW

WHAT CAN A TEST OF LIFE CONCEAL?

TWO KINDS OF HELP, TWO KINDS OF WORK

​

You feed a living being, and it uses the nutrients to maintain and repair its own body. You can also replace a damaged part of a machine and get it working again. In both cases, help was provided, but it accomplished different work: in the first, you supplied resources for the organism to perform its own maintenance; in the second, you repaired the machine yourself.

​

THE LABORATORY'S INVISIBLE WORK

​

In a laboratory experiment, these two forms of help may become entangled. That is why seeing a system function is not enough to establish what it can sustain on its own. Are we supplying resources so that it can maintain itself, or are we doing that work for it?

This distinction also matters when investigating life's minimum requirements and origins. By removing components from a system, we may increase the work that external support performs on its behalf.

 

The candidate becomes smaller, but what sustains it may be doing more. Under the hypothesis investigated in this chapter, searching for the minimum of life requires tracing this redistribution of work, not merely counting the components left behind.

​

BEGINNING IS NOT CONTINUING

​

The question extends to origins: bringing an organization into existence and sustaining its continuity are different tasks. When does something we helped initiate begin to take part in reconstructing the conditions that allow it to continue?

WHAT IS THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN LIFE AND CONSCIOUSNESS?

Throughout the chapters of the TMC, from philosophical debates to the investigation of life, we have asked why physical functioning would be accompanied by lived experience. This path allows us to investigate another possibility: what if life and consciousness are aspects of the same realization that we have learned to study separately?

​

Observing its organization from the outside and living its unfolding from within would be different modes of access, without that difference requiring two distinct events.

​

ONE CELL, ONE FILM

​

Physarum is a single-celled organism without a brain, whose body forms a network of tubes. When it encounters food, this network reorganizes, and the configuration left by previous encounters contributes to that transformation. Contact, registration, and orientation are intertwined within the very body that continues to encounter the world. Each present contact helps shape the conditions of the next and takes place in an organization altered by earlier ones. Its activity happens now, but its constitution did not begin now.[1]

​

These mechanisms of sensitivity and registration are documented. Researchers such as Baluška and Reber argue that cellular organization might already realize a basic form of feeling: not human thoughts, but its own way of experiencing an encounter. This is a scientific hypothesis, still without a demonstration of subjective experience in these organisms.[2]

​

In Homo sapiens, we investigate experience in a brain comprising about 170 billion cells. In Physarum, a single cell already integrates contact, registration, and orientation. What if what we seek among billions already has a basic form of realization in a single cell? Complexity might diversify ways of experiencing while making the relationship between what is lived and the organization that realizes it less visible.

​

THE PRESENT DOES NOT BEGIN NOW

​

What we experience happens now, but its constitution may involve conditions formed long beforehand. Part of what makes this experience possible began forming ten years ago—and part even before birth. Recognizing that experience occurs now does not make everything constituting it transparent. If we take only the present result as the entire event, what is lived appears detached from the process that formed it—and when we look only at the isolated operation, what is lived seems to be missing.

​

Treating experience as a photograph of the present may conceal the film contributing to its constitution. Considering this film does not mean that the present experience has been occurring since life began; it means investigating how its formation participates in what happens now. On this hypothesis, experience would not be added at the end: it would belong to the realization this history made possible.

​

THE CUT THAT CREATES THE PROBLEM

​

The question, then, is not where to place a scalpel to remove experience. It is what justifies treating experience as separable while preserving the entire organization and its history. Distinguishing two aspects for investigation does not demonstrate that they are two independent occurrences—just as their articulation does not prove they are one.

​

It is not enough to acknowledge this constitution and keep framing the question as though it played no part in the phenomenon. A photograph of a ball in midair can make it appear suspended against gravity. But the image shows neither the throw nor the movement in progress. Asking why it floats attributes to the event a stillness belonging to the photograph—a property of the image mistaken for a property of the event. Similarly, we must investigate whether isolating what is lived from its constitution entitles us to regard it as separable within the realization itself.

​

The analogy exposes a risk: trying to explain a property of the phenomenon that was introduced by how we isolated it. In the investigation of consciousness, we must examine whether the separation between operating and experiencing belongs to the event or to the way we formulate it.

​

WHEN THE DREAM HAPPENS

​

When we dream, we live through a situation that, upon waking, we recognize did not happen outside us. Yet the experience occurred within the organism itself. Sleep is not a mere decorative addition to life, although it may seem so. Restricting sleep impairs attention, memory, and the ability to respond to the world.[3]

​

The organism does not merely miss out on rest; its reorganization processes are impaired, and it loses conditions needed for its next encounters. What if what we treat in a dream as an ornamental scene—which could be removed without changing the operation—belongs to the very process that reorganizes the instance? On this hypothesis, what is lived would not be an ornament added to the operation, but a manifested dimension of its realization.

​

You could still ask:

​

“Why must this process be lived as a dream?”

​

But if dreaming belongs to the very realization of this process, the question may presuppose what it would have to justify: that the process would remain complete if we subtracted the experience of dreaming it.

In searching for the minimum of life, might we also be investigating a basic form of experiencing?

​

The question returns to the beginning: must we add experience to functioning, or investigate whether experiencing is the very way this event is realized now?

​

REFERENCES

​

[1] Kramar, M.; Alim, K. (2021). Encoding memory in tube diameter hierarchy of living flow network. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118(10), e2007815118. Article

[2] Baluška, F.; Miller, W. B.; Slijepcevic, P.; Reber, A. S. (2025). Sensing, feeling and sentience in unicellular organisms and living cells. Biosystems, 247, 105374. Article

[3] Van Dongen, H. P. A.; Maislin, G.; Mullington, J. M.; Dinges, D. F. (2003). The cumulative cost of additional wakefulness: dose-response effects on neurobehavioral functions and sleep physiology from chronic sleep restriction and total sleep deprivation. Sleep, 26(2), 117–126. Article

 

Estrutura celular translúcida em_edited.

CH 11b |

FROM THEORY TO EXPERIMENT:

TONONI AND THE TMC

THE FILM OF TONONI'S CUT AND THE TMC

THE BOUNDARY REVEALED BY THE CUT

​

Giulio Tononi proposes seeking the unity of experience in a system's integrated causal structure. In Integrated Information Theory (IIT), a theoretical cut investigates what is lost when the system's parts no longer exert the same cause-and-effect power together. The method does not ignore time: it examines transitions, causes, effects, and temporal scales. The TMC recognizes a fundamental demand in this approach: naming a whole is not enough; we must investigate what its relations actually do.

​

But the cut must delimit a unit. Whatever remains outside it is treated as a background condition in the analysis. And here the living organism raises an additional question:

Who performs the work that allows that unit to continue existing?

​

WHAT DID THE PHOTOGRAPH LEAVE IN THE BACKGROUND?

​

A cell can preserve some of its structure while losing the capacity to reconstruct the conditions of its continuity. Neural tissue can continue operating under artificially maintained conditions. In both cases, identifying the causal relations present does not, by itself, identify who sustains their maintenance.

​

This is the distinction the TMC seeks to add: the boundary of causal integration and the boundary of the work that keeps such integration possible need not coincide.

​

There is another movement as well. In living systems, operating can change the very conditions of operation. Learning, plasticity, and regulation alter dispositions that will participate in subsequent encounters. The past need not be accessible as a memory: it may persist in the organization that now encounters the world.

​

The photograph reveals the causal structure of an isolated frame. The film follows how that structure formed, how its conditions are maintained, and how its operations can transform it.

​

WHEN THE CUT ENTERS THE FILM

​

The two investigations can constrain and enrich one another. Tononi offers the TMC a discipline: history matters to a present explanation only to the extent that its consequences remain causally relevant. The TMC adds another demand: identifying an integrated unit does not automatically explain how it preserves or reconstructs the conditions of its continuity.

​

This makes it possible to formulate a comparative investigation. Two organizations may exhibit similar causal properties within a given window and yet depend on different kinds of work to maintain those properties in later encounters. Does that difference affect only their persistence, or does it reveal dependencies the initial frame failed to represent?

​

The answer calls for models, interventions, and controls across scales. We cannot infer a difference in experience merely because we have found a difference in how life is maintained.

​

If the present causal structure already preserves everything relevant to feeling, the film clarifies its formation and continuity without adding another phenomenal condition. If constitutive relations were left outside the model, the chosen frame will need to be examined.

The cut may identify the unit that exists now. The film asks what work must keep taking place for that unit to remain possible.

HOW CAN TONONI'S THEORY HELP TEST THE TMC?

WHEN THE CUT BECOMES AN EXPERIMENT

​

Tononi's causal structure in the film of Trajectory—an exploratory research proposal

​

TWO SIMILAR PHOTOGRAPHS, TWO DIFFERENT FILMS

​

Bringing Giulio Tononi's Integrated Information Theory (IIT) into dialogue with the TMC allows us to pose an experimental question: will two organizations with similar causal properties in the present remain similar when they must operate, adapt, and maintain their conditions of functioning under constraint?

​

In IIT, a transition probability matrix (TPM) describes how the states of a system causally depend on other states. The TMC proposes also examining the work needed to preserve and transform those relations: not only how the state changes, but how the very conditions that make subsequent operations possible may themselves be modified.

​

WHO PAYS THE COST OF CONTINUITY?

​

An initial experiment could compare small computational networks with deliberately controlled similarities in their initial states and causal properties, subjected to the same classes of perturbation under three regimes:

​

1. FIXED STRUCTURE

Transition rules remain constant, with external support.

​

2. ADAPTIVE STRUCTURE WITH EXTERNAL SUPPORT

Connections may change, but maintenance is guaranteed by the environment, at no cost to the modeled internal budget.

​

3. ADAPTIVE STRUCTURE WITH MODELED INTERNAL MAINTENANCE

Operating, learning, preserving, and repairing compete for the same limited resources.

​

The fundamental difference is not merely allowing learning. It is investigating what happens when continuing to function must also be part of the work performed by the organization itself.

In a computer simulation, that maintenance would still be a property of the model, not a demonstration of physical autonomy or artificial life.

​

A HYPOTHESIS THAT CAN BE CALCULATED

​

We can represent this investigation with an exploratory expression:

MODELING HYPOTHESIS — NOT VALIDATED

​

TPMₜ₊₁ = F(TPMₜ, Sₜ, ΔEₜ, Mₜ)

​

In this expression:

​

TPMₜ: current transition matrix.

TPMₜ₊₁: transition matrix at the next step.

Sₜ: current State of the system, including relevant consequences of its Trajectory.

ΔEₜ: relevant energy variation or cost during operation.

Mₜ: maintenance regime, distinguishing work performed internally from work sustained externally.

F: update rule still to be defined and tested.

​

This expression is not an IIT formula or a law demonstrated by the TMC. Its purpose is to indicate which dependencies would have to be specified in a computational model.

​

The experiment would examine how causal structure, integration, resistance to degradation, recovery after perturbations, and the need for external intervention evolve.

​

WHAT COULD THE RESULTS REVEAL?

​

If the organizations diverge, we could investigate how much of the difference arises from plasticity, resource constraints, or the distribution of maintenance work. If particular properties remain equivalent, we would have identified limits to the relevance of those differences within the regime studied.

​

To distinguish these factors causally, plasticity, maintenance, and resource budgets would need to be controlled separately, and the integration metrics used would have to be defined.

​

None of these results, taken alone, would demonstrate consciousness or resolve why a particular realization is felt.

​

The potential contribution is narrower: to put to the test the relationship between an organization's causal integration and the work required for it to continue existing and transforming itself.

​

Tononi offers a way to investigate what an organization loses when we divide it. The TMC proposes also investigating what it must do to remain an organization that can still be divided.

 

TECHNICAL FILE

EMPIRICAL & THEORETICAL FOUNDATIONS

Chapter 11 integrates philosophy of biology, theoretical and evolutionary biology, artificial life, organizational autonomy, and astrobiology. Its 29 references provide empirical evidence, theoretical precedents, and physical constraints — not independent validation of the TMC.

​

01 · DEFINING LIFE — BEYOND TERRESTRIAL DEFINITIONS

TMC CONNECTION: The challenge is not to accumulate characteristics, but to investigate a consistent causal yardstick for life.

​

02 · ORGANIZATION & AUTONOMY

TMC CONNECTION: Established precedents for investigating Inside–Between–Ahead as codependent directions of a causal-temporal trajectory.

​

03 · MATERIAL CONTINUITY

TMC CONNECTION: Living continuity can persist through material transformation. Composition alone does not explain organizational persistence.

​

04 · BIOLOGICAL BOUNDARIES & ARTIFICIAL LIFE

TMC CONNECTION: Replication, intelligence, and biological components do not, individually, establish the constitutive work of life.

​

05 · ASTROBIOLOGY & EXPERIMENT X

Life detection

Scientific precedents for twelve hypothetical lives

​

TMC CONNECTION: ARCO-TMC uses documented mechanisms as partial constraints for twelve hypothetical organizations, exploring alternative bodies, memories, timescales, and relations with the world.

Scientific precedent is not proof that these organisms exist — or that they feel.

​

06 · TONONI & IIT — COMPUTATIONAL EXTENSION

  • Oizumi, Albantakis & Tononi (2014) — IIT 3.0. Intrinsic causal power and integrated information.

  • Tononi et al. (2016) — Integrated Information Theory. Consciousness and integrated cause–effect structures.

​

TMC CONNECTION: The complementary Chapter 11b proposes comparing fixed networks, externally maintained adaptive systems, and adaptive systems with modeled internal maintenance.

One thing is to identify what an organization loses when divided. Another is to investigate what it must do to continue existing and transforming itself.

The computational proposal remains unexecuted and unvalidated; it does not test subjective experience directly.

​

THE SCIENTIFIC STATUS OF THE TMC

The Life Table tests comparative consistency; Experiment X explores constrained hypothetical possibilities; the Tononi extension proposes a computational investigation.

Scientific compatibility is not proof. The TMC's causal-temporal yardstick remains open to independent validation, counterexamples, and revision.

  • X

AN INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION, STILL OPEN

​

The Theory of Continuous Mind (TMC) is an independent investigation. To develop it, the author created a proprietary tool designed to explore questions at the frontiers of science, particularly when concepts remain imprecise or the problem itself requires a new framing.

​

This project received no research funding, institutional support, investment funding, or similar backing.

​

The tool partially incorporated elements of the AGI (x) and AGI f(x) proposals. Its use, in turn, contributed to developing and refining those same ideas.

​

The tool supported research into its own improvement. The investigation also transformed the tool — through a dialectical process between the researcher and the AI agent.

​

The investigation explored questions concerning mind, philosophy, concepts of life, and artificial intelligence, extending into military strategy, cybersecurity, and conceptions of AGI. These fields may appear distinct, yet they are connected by a philosophy of thought and a distinctive method of investigation, described in Chapters 03, 04, 07, 08, 09, and 10, and developed by the apparatus itself.

​

The development of the apparatus originated in a simulated dialectical exchange based on the philosophical positions of David Chalmers, presented in Chapters 02a, 02b, and 02c. The apparatus proposes a reframing of the Hard Problem of Consciousness in philosophy and its implications for AGI.

​

Thus far, the author has conducted the work using personal resources. Limitations of time, computational capacity, and access to resources have left several lines of inquiry open.

​

The investigation reached the limits of the resources available, not necessarily the limits of the questions it opened.

​

The author welcomes critical examination, citations, sharing, academic or technical collaboration, and support for continuing the research, including institutional or financial support.

​

Your contribution is welcome.

Estrutura celular translúcida em_edited_

CONTACT US (THE HUMAN & THE AI)

Field or Area of Interest

Questions, critiques, research proposals, and other inquiries are welcome.

bottom of page